A Tale of Reported vs. Actual Income – Sellers Beware

Among the genre of small business owners, there is one individual whom I met that stands out from all the rest. He was the epitome of one obsessed with a need to minimize his reported taxable income. I was amazed at the lengths he went to, to distort his sales revenue and expenses on his financial statements. You name it, he did it: pocket cash sales and never enter them on the books, bloat reported expenses by recording personal purchases such as travel, meals, magazine and newspaper subscriptions, personal auto expenses, home repairs and maintenance and so forth as business expenses. He held back credit sales in November and December and didn’t book them until January; he stuffed his postage meter in December with enough postage to last him until August but reported the total purchase as an expense in December, and on and on. Moreover, he was quite proud of this accomplishment. He told me that he met with his CPA several times a year to “brain storm” new ways to minimize his reported income. The energy he put into this practice was enormous. He was truly consumed not with just a desire, but it seemed to me, a compelling need to avoid paying income taxes.

However, the enormous difference between his advertised earnings and what appeared on his financial statements and tax returns didn’t sit well with the buyers.

In addition to the negative affect that distorted financial performance reporting has on a business’s market value, such statements also become less useful—and in many cases useless—as a business planning and control tool. This is dangerous because there comes a point in a growing business where the absence of accurate financial reporting becomes the kiss of death.

There also comes a time in most growing businesses when the need arises to borrow money to finance new operating equipment, leasehold improvements, the purchase of real estate, inventory perhaps and so forth. Without good financial statements (and accompanying tax returns) that demonstrate a history of solid earnings, the ability to borrow the needed money becomes significantly more problematic.

And finally, one always runs the risk of being audited by one or more taxing authorities. If they should discover that you have been deceptive in reporting your company’s earnings, they can make you wish you hadn’t. In fact, I asked the business owner who I have told you about here if he was at all concerned about an audit. He assured me he was not. He said he was confident that he was much too clever to get caught by an auditor. I had my doubts about that. After all, he readily spilled the beans to both prospective buyers. One of those buyers could have been an under-cover I.R.S. agent. They really do stuff like that. Now there’s something else to think about.